×
This forum has been locked. Please submit new Feature Requests on GitHub: github.com/Jensen-Technologies/component-creator-issues/issues
Public Component Library
Neil
New Member
Posts: 6
10 år 2 uger siden #466
af Neil
Public Component Library blev oprettet af Neil
Hi All,
I think it would be a great idea to have a public component library area which works like this...
I think it would be a great idea to have a public component library area which works like this...
- Lets say you have built a component that you think others may find useful. Alongside the 'Build' button, there is another button to 'Publish' to the public library (subject to moderation).
- Before building your own component from scratch, other users can view the public library for similar components for anything which they think may suit their needs (or even halfway there). They would then have the option to download a version of it into their own library, then change their version as they see fit.
Følgende bruger(e) sagde tak: Matthew Wilmshorst
Venligst Log på eller Opret en konto for at deltage i samtalen
Andres Maeso
Platinum Member
Posts: 338
10 år 2 uger siden #468
af Andres Maeso
Andrés Maeso
Customer relations manager at Joomla Component Creator.
Denne e-mail adresse bliver beskyttet mod spambots. Du skal have JavaScript aktiveret for at vise den.
Besvaret af Andres Maeso på emne Public Component Library
Hi Neil!
Thanks for the idea! We had a similar one some time ago, but I like the way you exposed it. Let's see if it gets more votes and we will consider how to develop it
Thanks for the idea! We had a similar one some time ago, but I like the way you exposed it. Let's see if it gets more votes and we will consider how to develop it
Andrés Maeso
Customer relations manager at Joomla Component Creator.
Denne e-mail adresse bliver beskyttet mod spambots. Du skal have JavaScript aktiveret for at vise den.
Venligst Log på eller Opret en konto for at deltage i samtalen
Randy Carey
Junior Member
Posts: 23
10 år 2 uger siden #469
af Randy Carey
Besvaret af Randy Carey på emne Public Component Library
The most value this would have for me is to see the ideas of others - particularly, the type of components they are building. But because what is saved is what is generated, the items in such a library would be very rough and require additional work. I assume the library will not be curated. So there is no guarantee that any component that is shared works correctly or has meaningful connections among fields and related tables. And if someone revises a build and tries to share it again, what is stored (duplicate copies or an updated copy)?
So for me, whenever I come across a need for a custom component, I probably will always conduct my own data modeling and build the initial component to my specific specifications. But I can see a library of shared builds to have value for those who are challenged by data modeling and need to see examples.
So for me, whenever I come across a need for a custom component, I probably will always conduct my own data modeling and build the initial component to my specific specifications. But I can see a library of shared builds to have value for those who are challenged by data modeling and need to see examples.
Venligst Log på eller Opret en konto for at deltage i samtalen
Neil
New Member
Posts: 6
10 år 2 uger siden #470
af Neil
Besvaret af Neil på emne Public Component Library
Hi Randy
You're right in what you say about components needing extra work, and the idea is meant to be a starting block for others to tailor to suit their needs.
As an example, one of the components I'm currently building is a simple 'For Sale' component for a company's intranet. I'd say at least 75% of the controls in there would be transferrable and applicable for someone else to use for a similar component, without having to build all that information in from scratch. I'm sure there must be many more examples out there where people have already created something similar to each other.
I did suggest some kind of moderation to ensure only appropriate and tested components end up in the public library.
Thats an interesting point regarding duplicate copies, and if your 'updated' version ends up being better than the original, why not submit it again for approval?
There will of course still be many occasions whereby you have to start from scratch, which is why we've got this fantastic development tool, I just think the public library may just cut down the amount of 're-inventing the wheel' and save even more time.
You're right in what you say about components needing extra work, and the idea is meant to be a starting block for others to tailor to suit their needs.
As an example, one of the components I'm currently building is a simple 'For Sale' component for a company's intranet. I'd say at least 75% of the controls in there would be transferrable and applicable for someone else to use for a similar component, without having to build all that information in from scratch. I'm sure there must be many more examples out there where people have already created something similar to each other.
I did suggest some kind of moderation to ensure only appropriate and tested components end up in the public library.
Thats an interesting point regarding duplicate copies, and if your 'updated' version ends up being better than the original, why not submit it again for approval?
There will of course still be many occasions whereby you have to start from scratch, which is why we've got this fantastic development tool, I just think the public library may just cut down the amount of 're-inventing the wheel' and save even more time.
Venligst Log på eller Opret en konto for at deltage i samtalen
Tid til at oprette siden: 0.055 sekunder